Fed’s Warsh Sets Out Three Super Intelligence Scenarios, From Shared Gains to a Slowdown
The Takeaway: Federal Reserve Chairman Kevin Warsh set out three ways super intelligence could play out for the US economy: broadly shared productivity gains, growth that displaces jobs, or a disappointment that brings a slowdown. Board staff built them as illustrative scenarios, not forecasts. Third-quarter data show strong productivity growth but labor’s share of output at 53.0%, the lowest in a series that begins in 1947.
Opening a Fed conference in San Francisco on Monday, his first visit to a Reserve Bank as Chairman, Kevin Warsh said super intelligence “demands our special attention”.
Three illustrative paths, from shared gains to a slowdown
The Board’s staff has begun to evaluate contingencies, applying “stylized, model-based frameworks” to generate scenarios, Warsh said. He called them “illustrative scenarios, not forecasts”, and said many other outcomes, “probably including one that will prove most accurate”, could be drawn.
In the first, super intelligence lifts productivity, with economic gains “shared broadly across labor and the owners of capital”. Real GDP growth then runs persistently above its long-run average, and the United States stays close to full employment.
The second keeps GDP growth above its long-term average but could bring “substantial labor market disruption” as some jobs are displaced, rather than complemented, by technology. Widespread automation, combined with labor market frictions, could push the jobless rate above levels consistent with full employment, the Chairman said.
In the third, the technology disappoints. “After significant capital investment and stock market gains, expected returns could turn down and equity valuations could fall, leading to an economic slowdown and a more notable rise in unemployment,” Warsh said. The economy would recover in time, “but without the productivity gains”.
The Fed’s role in all this is “neither advocacy nor opposition”, he said. Widespread adoption “will have significant impact on the economy, with important implications for monetary policy down the road.”
The big questions, he said, “are about magnitude, scope, and timing.” The first on his list was whether the technology will deliver a rise in total factor productivity, the output growth not explained by more workers or more capital.
Productivity has been reasonably strong but has not broken out, Warsh says
The Fed Chairman built his case on the economics of ideas. An idea is nonrival, so one person’s use does not diminish anyone else’s, and its value grows with the number of people who use it. Citing the Nobel laureate Paul Romer, he said a doubling of ideas and other key inputs can more than double output.
Breakthrough ideas have been harder to find in the United States, Warsh said. By some estimates, research efforts have increased more than 20 times since the 1930s, while, as Nick Bloom, Charles I. Jones and their coauthors found, “research productivity has fallen by an even larger amount”.
“Productivity growth has fluctuated, and in recent quarters, it’s been reasonably strong. But it hasn’t yet broken out definitively and structurally to the upside,” he said.
What might set super intelligence apart, he argued, is that it could supercharge the generation of ideas. It appears to be changing both the method and the speed of innovation, he said. The internal combustion engine and electricity brought decades of follow-on innovation but did not themselves automate the creation of ideas, he said. He was equally clear on limits: “Humans are the designers and the builders, and humans must be the deciders.”
The latest data show fast output, a steady jobless rate and a smaller labor share
The official figures match the word “fluctuated”. Nonfarm business productivity rose at a 3.6% annual rate in the third quarter, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported on 5 November, after a revised 2.1% in the second.
Over the seven quarters from the start of 2025, the quarterly rates ranged from a 0.1% decline to a 4.5% rise.
The longer trend is back at its historical pace. Productivity has grown at a 2.2% annual rate in the business cycle that began in the fourth quarter of 2019, the bureau said. That matches its long-term rate since 1947.
The previous cycle, from the end of 2007 to the end of 2019, managed 1.5%.
Workers have taken a smaller slice. The labor share, the part of output paid to workers as compensation, was 53.0% in the third quarter, the lowest level in a series that begins in 1947.
Real hourly compensation, which allows for consumer prices, rose at a 1.1% annual rate in the quarter. Productivity rose more than three times as fast.
Nonfarm business productivity and output (annualized change in %)
| Quarter | Per hour | Output |
|---|---|---|
| Q1 2025 | -0.1 | -0.1 |
| Q2 2025 | 4.2 | 5.2 |
| Q3 2025 | 4.5 | 4.7 |
| Q4 2025 | 1.2 | 1.0 |
| Q1 2026 | 1.4 | 2.1 |
| Q2 2026 | 2.1 | 2.4 |
| Q3 2026 | 3.6 | 3.7 |
“Per hour” is labor productivity, output per hour worked. Seasonally adjusted annual rates of change from the previous quarter; the third quarter of 2026 is preliminary.
Output picked up in the third quarter. Real GDP grew at a 3.4% annual rate in the third quarter, the Bureau of Economic Analysis estimated on 29 October, after 2.2% in the second.
The pickup from the second quarter mainly reflected faster investment and an upturn in government spending, partly offset by lower exports, the bureau said. Investment rose mostly on inventories and equipment, where information processing equipment, mainly computers and peripherals, led.
Fed policymakers’ September projections put the median longer-run growth rate at 2.0%. That is a projection for the economy over the longer run, not a benchmark for any single quarter’s annualized rate.
The unemployment rate has barely moved. It was 4.1% in October, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said. It has stayed between 4.1% and 4.3% since March.
Latest readings and policymakers’ longer-run medians (in %)
| Measure | Latest | Median |
|---|---|---|
| Real GDP growth, Q3 2026 | 3.4 | 2.0 |
| Unemployment rate, October 2026 | 4.1 | 4.2 |
Latest: the advance estimate of real GDP growth at an annual rate, and the October unemployment rate. Median: the longer-run projection of Federal Open Market Committee participants, September 2026, not a quarterly benchmark.
The policy rate stays at 3.75% to 4.00%
The opening remarks carried no signal on interest rates. The Federal Open Market Committee held the target range for the federal funds rate at 3.75% to 4.00% on 28 October.
Two voters, Lisa D. Cook and Beth M. Hammack, dissented, preferring a quarter-point increase. The statement said “productivity growth is strong, and capital investment is robust”, while inflation “remains elevated”.
A task force led from outside the Fed
The productivity and jobs task force is one of five that Warsh has convened as Chairman. Its brief is to assess the economic impact of new general-purpose technologies, including artificial intelligence, to inform the Fed’s policy judgments, the Board said when it named the leaders on 9 July.
Marc Andreessen of Andreessen Horowitz, Jones, a Stanford University economist currently on leave at Anthropic, and Asha Sharma of Microsoft co-lead it. The other groups cover communications, balance sheet policy, data and inflation frameworks.
The Board and the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco hosted the conference, which opened at 17:00 GMT and was livestreamed. Warsh moderated two panels and the closing fireside chat, with Andreessen and Gina Raimondo, a former US Secretary of Commerce, according to the Reserve Bank’s agenda. Mary C. Daly, its president, moderated a panel on how businesses adopt the technology.
In The Edge’s reading, one quarter cannot place the economy on any of Warsh’s three paths, which he sets out as outcomes over the next several years. Third-quarter growth and unemployment resemble some of the conditions of his first path, while trend productivity is still at its long-term rate. The figures do not show whether super intelligence is already generating those gains or how any benefits would ultimately be shared.
What to watch: The Bureau of Economic Analysis publishes its second estimate of third-quarter GDP on 25 November at 13:30 GMT. The Federal Open Market Committee meets on 8 and 9 December, with new economic projections.
Method: quotes are from Chairman Kevin Warsh’s opening remarks posted on federalreserve.gov on 16 November 2026; the agenda is from the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco’s conference page, and the task force details from the Board’s press release of 9 July 2026; policy is from the Federal Open Market Committee statement of 28 October 2026 and projections from its Summary of Economic Projections of 16 September 2026; productivity and the labor share are from the Bureau of Labor Statistics release of 5 November 2026, unemployment from its release of 6 November 2026, and GDP from the Bureau of Economic Analysis advance estimate of 29 October 2026; ratios not attributed to a source are The Edge’s calculations.
Sources: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, US Bureau of Labor Statistics, US Bureau of Economic Analysis, The Edge.



